Flat Abs Myth: Why Calories Don’t Count

by Katrina Eden

It’s easy to get caught up in the latest, greatest, newest or trendiest ‘flat abs’ fad. The only catch is that it’s pretty confusing to keep up with them all…and that’s without questioning whether the new trick you might be trying actually works.

One of the things we’ve tried to do with this blog is keep it simple.

Having a flat belly does take a bit of work so a large part of our goal has been to try and make that job easier for you. Exercise, nutrition, stress, hormones, lifestyle – they’re all equally important – not only to your flat belly goals, but to your greater health and wellbeing.

One simple rule…

One the simplest, most successfully tried and tested flat ab rules however is the ‘energy in’ versus ‘energy out’ rule.

What this means is simply that if you consume less energy (from food) than what you expend (burn off from exercise, movement, daily life), then you’ll be a lean, mean, ripped ab machine in no time.

It sounds pretty easy doesn’t it? So why doesn’t this work for everyone?

Maybe you’re someone who does all the ‘right’ things, eats ‘healthy’ foods, hits the gym every night and but you just can’t seem to beat the bulge. It’s frustrating, confusing and annoying, isn’t it?

Here’s what they didn’t tell you about energy in vs energy out rule:

The first thing you need to know is that the basic concept is sound. If you expend more energy than what you consume you will lose weight…but here’s where it gets interesting.

1 - How do you define energy? Is it a calorie?

Try counting the calories you eat and weighing them up against the alleged calories burnt on different gym machines. Not much fun, and I bet it doesn’t work. There’s no accounting for how much muscle mass you have – which is actually what dictates how much energy you burn while exercising, as well as after.

What you see on the treadmill or read in a magazine basically means nothing. Energy in vs energy out isn’t about calories.

2 - The way your body uses a calorie from food is completely unique.

What does this mean? Just because fat has 9 calories per gram and carbohydrate 4, does not mean that eating carbs rather than fat is the way to go. For some people, a high calorie diet, rich in natural proteins and fats, will actually keep them lean. Others will look and feel their best on a comparatively low calorie diet, dominant in fruits, salads and grains. Pretty confusing! But simple to figure out.

Your individual nutritional needs are determined by your body and your body’s needs alone. One way that helps you determine this is by finding out your metabolic type.

3 - The amount of energy (body fat) you will expend is determined by your overall health.

Good health is a reflection of balance. So if you’re:

  • Very stressed
  • Not sleeping enough
  • Sleeping too much
  • Under or over exercising
  • Just having a bad day,

…then you might have an excess of stress hormones coursing through your body. This means your body will hold onto fat regardless of how you eat or exercise. Just another reason to take some serious time out over the festive season.

So what does this all mean ?

Energy in vs energy out is still a great rule to follow. The main thing I want you to keep in mind is that you are unique. What works for your training buddy or partner may not work for you. Listen to your body, try to work hard but also rest hard, and remember that low calories and long training sessions are not necessarily the answer.

Banner for book
  1. 4 Responses to “Flat Abs Myth: Why Calories Don’t Count”

  2. Speaking of energy usage, how about the “after 6 diet” wherein you stop eating anything after 6pm, ever heard about how effective it really is?

    The theory is that after 6pm, a person is usually less active so not eating anything after 6pm will be beneficial for those wanting to lose weight.

    What do you think of it?

    By Petra on Dec 8, 2007

  3. You make a great point about how the amount of energy your body uses is dependent on your overall health. Excess stress will kill most of your fat loss goals.

    Funily, I’ve just written a piece on fat loss and energy intake vs. expenditure on my blog so this was a good read for me, thanks.

    By Mike on Dec 9, 2007

  4. I like this site, but this article is poorly written IMO, sorry. You start by debunking the ‘energy in’ versus ‘energy out’ rule but then close by saying it’s “still a great rule to follow” … you suggest learning about metabolic type, but make no mention of how to actually use this information. Everyone is unique? Of course they are. I think you should re-visit this topic with better action items.

    By Adam on Dec 12, 2007

  5. @Adam - thanks for the feedback, it’s noted and all the contributors (who as the editor of this blog, I believe are doing a fantastic job here - for free) are now aware of the need to write more usefully about metabolic typing and focus on specific action points, where relevant, in their posts .

    Is there anything specific you’d like to know about MT?

    By Editor on Dec 14, 2007

Post a Comment